Her lifeless body was hanging by a cord from a bunk bed in her cell. Listen in to EP2: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? In a TV interview in November 2015, Amber's parents discussed their daughter's death with McGraw. An Oklahoma woman has killed herself in prison five years after she was convicted of pushing her husband to his death from their high-rise apartment, the Oklahoma Department of Corrections confirmed to PEOPLE. Family Member, Friend or Colleague of a Guest. In 2016, a year after speaking to Dr. Phil McGraw and three years after she was convicted for the murder of her husband, Amber died in prison. On whether she intended to push her husband out the window: No, I didnt. Nebraska cheerleader competes by herself at state competition, but crowd doesn't let her feel alone, Jim Inhofe looks back on his career: 'I really wanted to make a difference, and I did', State superintendent questions whether Oklahoma students should attend state colleges and universities, 'They don't make them like her anymore': Historic 1914 bungalow in The Heights restored with love, Bed Bath & Beyond to close two stores in Tulsa, Former NFL star Chad Johnson says he saved money by living inside Cincinnati Bengals stadium for 2 years, Gatesway Hot Air Balloon Festival returning after 6-year hiatus, Last day for Utica Square store is Friday, Meet the 2023 Mr. Inside/Mr. "The window wasn't supposed to happen. Amber Hilberling, who was 19 and pregnant at the time of her husband's death, was convicted of second degree murder despite her insistence that her husband, Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil. TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@drphil You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. Phil during a TV interview Corns surrendered his law license last April amid an Oklahoma Bar Association probe into his conduct and cannot apply for reinstatement for five years. A statement from the mother of Josh Hilberling brought up the idea that taking a plea deal could have precluded the civil lawsuit. Hilberling said she was a "good wife" and denied being a violent person. And he didnt care, Hilberling said. But, she maintained her innocence, stating that it had been an accident. Amber Hilberling was charged with second-degree murder in the March 2013 death of her husband, Josh Hilberling, despite her insistence that she acted in self-defense when, during an argument, she pushed him and he fell to his death out a window of their high rise apartment in Tulsa, Oklahoma. DID YOU PUSH HIM? DR. PHIL TO AMBER HILBERLING video created by Dr. Phil: 21K views, 82 likes, 0 loves, 37 You can cancel at any time. Amber Hilberling was sentenced to 25 years and needed to serve just over 21 years before becoming eligible for parole. They painted me as a monster. Amber Hilberling filed a lawsuit Sept. 19, 2012, against University Club Tower(click here to read the story),alleging that Joshua Hilberling's wrongful death was a result of negligence on the part of the apartment and its owners. He was accused of developing a personal relationship with an elderly client in 2010 that went far beyond the professional attorney-client structure and accepting $1 million in gifts and loans from her. Dr. Phil makes regular appearances on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, Jimmy Kimmel Live, and The Late Late Show with James Corden. She also appeared in several documentaries, with her last interview being Channel 4sWomen Who Kill,after which something tragic happened to the 25-year old mother of two. TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@drphil Seeking Interesting People Who Play Solitaire Grand Harvest. Joshua Hilberling's estate has a pending lawsuit(click here to read the story)against University Club Tower, Horizon Realty Management Inc. and Budget Glass Cleaning Inc. Amber Hilberling's police-room conversation with her grandmother(click here to see the video) was played in court. She went on to say that when he did so, I pushed him off me. Push my husband and make him fall. Amber's family has had custody of her and Josh's son Levi since she was sent to prison, ABC Tulsa reports. Fortunately, you can help. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner preliminarily ruled Amber's death as suicide by hanging. Are You Involved in a Story Making Headlines? Hilberling, who was 7 months pregnant at the time of her husbands death in 2011, had maintained her innocence, saying that she pushed Josh in self-defense during an argument and he fell backward through the window of the couples 25th-floor Tulsa, Oklahoma apartment. She was sentenced to 25 years behind bars upon her conviction. Mystery and Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil, hear excerpts from his interview with Amber Hilberling during her incarceration. Amber Hilberling was seven months pregnant at the time of her husband's death. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News 9 delivered right to your inbox! Want Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam? In the video, she called herself a horrible person and asked what kind of person would push her husband to make him fall out of a window. You have permission to edit this collection. And he didnt care, Hilberling said. We spill the beans on what transpired after that infamous interview with McGraw in February 2016 that took us behind the scenes of the life and times of Amber and Josh Hilberling. Amber and Joshua Hilberling had a history of domestic violence claims, and each spouse's family accused the other spouse of violence. (Click here to read the story.) Amber Hilberling, who was 19 and pregnant at the time of her husband's death, was convicted of second degree murder despite her insistence that her husband, Josh's, fall was an accident. Amber spoke to the Dr. Phil show from behind bars and proclaimed her innocence. Amber Michelle Hilberling and Josh Hilberling were a young, newly-wed couple and new parents at the time of Joshs death. The expectant mother remembers pushing her 6ft 6 husband away from her, and then looking at a broken window. And I was pregnant. Get the latest in local public safety news with this weekly email. On the statements she made to her grandmother in a police interrogation room before her interview. The original suit, filed by Amber Hilberling, is still pending. Each full episode contains an interview or multiple interviews with doctors, teens, families, parents, kids, and more. The firefighter testified that Hilberling said: "I didn't mean to do it. The injuries that were shown in the pictures speak for themselves. The plea deals would have allowed her to negotiate a 5-year sentence in prison and 15 years probation or seven years in prison and 13 years of a suspended sentence. On March 18, 2013, jurors found Hilberling guilty of second-degree murder, and in April, the judge upheld the recommendation, giving her a 25-year prison sentence. Wondering what happened to Amber on Dr. Phil? In a February appearance on Dr. Phil, Amber further detailed her side of the altercation, alleging, "He reached out and grabbed me. Two wrongful-death lawsuits have been filed against University Club Tower since 2012, the second resulting from the dismissal of the first for a deadline error. TM & 2023 Peteski Productions, Inc. 2023 CBS Interactive Inc.. a Paramount company. The petition alleges that the window was not made of the type of glass required by city of Tulsa building code. And he didn't care. The deal wouldve prevented her from personally suing the apartment building owners? We upload new videos every day, so make sure you subscribe and ring the bell for all notifications, so you don't miss a single one. Amber Hilberling filed a lawsuit Sept. 19, 2012, against University Club Tower(click here to read the story),alleging that Joshua Hilberling's wrongful death was a result of negligence on the part of the apartment and its owners. Then cast your vote, Bruce Springsteen adds to mythology with three-hour show at Tulsa's BOK Center, State board approves new academic standards with Ryan Walters' last-minute revisions, More than 800 Oklahoma medical marijuana farms linked to organized crime, drug agency says, Gov. Visit Feeding America to find your local food bank. Click here to read the story. She also was heard sayingthat her dead husband's parents were right: "They kept saying if we stayed together, I'm going to kill him. In episode 4 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Amber served only three years of her 25-year prison term. On her defense attorney having no experience with criminal cases: I understood when my parents bailed me out initially that he had been a friend of theirs. When Amber was accused of pushing her husband to his death from their University Club apartment, the story spread from Tulsa across national boundaries. Oklahoma Department of Corrections spokesman Alex Gerszewski said Hilberling, 25, was found hanging from the bunk bed in the cell of a medium-security housing unit at the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud about 5:20 p.m. Monday. We promise to never spam you. When you visit this site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Both families have lost a child. Phil episode that aired Thursday. Plus learn what Dr. Phil says about the process of appealing a court decision. The fight then escalated, and ultimately ended in Josh's death. He loved to break my phone all the time so I wouldnt have any way of communicating if he wasnt home, she said. I want to be dead. Dr. Phil tells compelling stories about real people. Click here to read the story. Sponsored: Dr. Phil McGraw Teams Up With Sundae To Help Homeowners Sell As-Is. The suit was dismissed in March 2015. Here is a timeline of events from the case: Amber Michelle Hilberling, 19,was seven months pregnant when she was jailed June 7, 2011(click here to read the story), after her husband fell from the 25th floor of the University Club tower to his death. How their fairytale love story turned sour baffled many who knew the two. Amber Hilberling was charged with second-degree murder in the March 2013 death of her husband, Josh Hilberling, despite her insistence that she acted in self Dr. Phil has also done crossovers with 90 Day Fianc and Inside Edition. He reached out and grabbed me. Sponsored: Dr. Phil McGraw Teams Up With Sundae To Help Homeowners Sell As-Is. During her interview with McGraw, Whitlock alleged that, after Amber's death, a member of Josh's family sent her a hurtful message about her daughter via social media. Dr. Phil is the top-rated daytime talk show attracting millions of viewers every day alongside other talk shows, including The Ellen Show with Ellen DeGeneres, The Dr. Oz Show, The Kelly Clarkson Show, and The Steve Wilkos Show. Seven months pregnant at the time, Amber said she didn't intend for the 23-year-old Josh to die. Amber Hilberling was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 25 years behind bars for the 2013 death of her husband, Josh. Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/drphilshow ", Amber Hilberling and her attorneysrejected two plea deals from the District Attorney's Office(click here to read the story)that would have negotiated a sentence of five years in prison plus 15 years of probation or a sentence of seven years in prison with 13 years suspended. That was our relationship: Josh getting in trouble over and over again and me saying, Oh, no, its not his fault. TM & 2023 Peteski Productions, Inc. 2023 CBS Interactive Inc.. a Paramount company. The Department of Corrections said it could not comment on anything regarding Hilberling's health while she was in prison because it would violate privacy laws. Hilberling later told "Dateline NBC"(click here to read the story)thatshe didn't regret the decision and turned down the plea deal because a person who is not guilty is "going to take any risk that is necessary to prove it. And I was pregnant. We are praying for peace for everyone, including Joshs family and friends, Jeanne Hilberling said. That firm sent the News On 6 a statement, that says in part, "While the circumstances surrounding Amber's death remain unclear, the prevalence of contraband inside correctional facilities is often associated with funding deficiencies imposed by the Legislature. Self-Care: So, How Do We Get Started With 'Connection'? She says it was an accident but was arrested and put on trial for murder. And, I mean, theres always going to be a level of guilt because Im alive and hes not.. Josh's wife, Amber, says it was an accident, but she was arrested and put on trial for murder. The show provides the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television. She was sentenced to 25 years behind bars upon her conviction. Amber also says that Josh was kicked out of the U.S Air Force for drug abuse, and that's why they were in Tulsa, the Daily Star reports. Dr. Phil is the top-rated daytime talk show attracting millions of viewers every day alongside other talk shows, including The Ellen Show with Ellen DeGeneres, The Dr. Oz Show, The Kelly Clarkson Show, and The Steve Wilkos Show. Use tab to navigate through the menu items. (Click here to read the story.). ", Amber Hilberling testified that she pushed Joshua Hilberling in self-defense because he had grabbed her shoulder when he grew frustrated during an argument and she couldn't have anticipated the window breaking, allowing Joshua to fall to his death. For over a decade, Dr. McGraw has used the show's platform to make psychology accessible to the general public by addressing important personal and social issues. "She was depressed, not suicidal," Whitlock had said on the Dr. Phil show. Hilberling was convicted in 2013 of second-degree murder in the death of her husband, Josh Hilberling, and was serving a 25-year sentence, NBC News reports. In addition to the $10,000 fine imposed by the jury, Amber Hilberling was ordered to reimburse the more than $6,000 in funeral expenses paid by her deceased husband's family. Mystery and Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil. However, in October 2016, after filming had ended, Amber Hilberling died in prison while still serving her 25-year sentence, per the Washington Post. Joshua Hilberling's brother Zach Hilberling (third from left) is pictured with their parents, Patrick Hilberling and Jeanne Hilberling. Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Do you want to be on the show? The story of the young, picture-perfect couple rapidly went from local news to grabbing national headlines. Sign up for our newsletter to keep reading. 13.30 Srie TV Dr Quinn, femme mdecin Une visite inattendue. Outside candidates. The Channel 4 explores the circumstances surrounding Josh's death, including interviewing Hiberling about what happened. Get the latest in local public safety news with this weekly email. On May 17, 2013,"Dateline NBC" devoted about an hour to telling Amber Hilberling's story, using interviews with Hilberling, her family, Joshua Hilberling's family, attorneys, police investigators and even a window expert who opined on the strength of the glass at University Club Tower. After her death in prison Oct. 24, 2016(story here),Hilberlings parents appeared on Dr. she had rejected a plea deal for a five-year sentence with an added 15 years of probation. In a jailhouse interview in 2015 with Dr. Phil McGraw, Amber Hilberling explained that she had pushed her 23-year-old husband through an apartment window in self-defence but insisted she didnt mean to kill him. I think youre here because your story didnt get told in an effective way, he said. FB: https://www.facebook.com/DrPhilInTheBlanks/, Amber Hilberling tells her side of the story in an interview with Dr. Phil in episode 4 Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Amber Hilberling, 25, was found hanging from the bunk bed of her cell by another inmate on Monday at 5:20 p.m., according to a news release from the DOC. I want Josh to be here. And I was pregnant. The petition alleges that the window was not made of the type of glass required by city of Tulsa building code. Are You Involved in a Story Making Headlines? Copyright 2023 Peteski Productions, Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | Terms of Use | Privacy. She could be heard saying "I'm a horrible person. She went on to say that when he did so, I pushed him off me. The window wasnt supposed to happen.Phillip Phil McGraw traveled to Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud to interview Hilberling. Dr. Phil has also done crossovers with 90 Day Fianc and Inside Edition. Want Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam? Please subscribe to keep reading. ApplePodcasts: https://apple.co/2YfGnGG 25 2019, and is available to watch on All 4. Prosecutors offered the pregnant 19-year-old the option to serve five years in exchange for a guilty plea, but Amber refused the deal. Hilberling's mother had just posted a photo of her daughter on Facebook Sunday, saying how much she was missing her. McGraw revisited the case in an November 2016 episode after Hilberling's death. Family Member, Friend or Colleague of a Guest. Click here to read the story. WebDr. Do you want to be on the show? Amber Hilberling, now 24, was seven months pregnant when 23-year-old Josh Hilberling fell 17 stories from the University Club Tower on June 7, 2011. Update: Suicide in prison ruled cause of death for Amber Hilberling, convicted of killing husband. Phil during a TV interviewthat aired Feb. 4, 2016. He was a member of the military but was released due in part to what Amber Hilberling said were drug-related issues. Amber Hilberling was convicted of second-degree murder in 2013, following an incident in which her husband Josh was pushed through an apartment window and fell to his death. This video is unavailable because we were unable to load a message from our sponsors. You have permission to edit this article. A judge upheld the jury's recommendation of a 25-year prison term. I did that. . My parents tried to get me several times over the course of the two years that we were fighting the case to fire him because they didnt believe that he was competent, Hiberling said. It was all gibberish to me. 2. Phil and told the television hosttheir daughter had cut herself while in prison but they believed she was murdered (story here). But in a shocking twist and in a move that would later come to haunt her, Amber refused the deal. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. She decided to take her chances and go to trial. Are You Involved in a Story Making Headlines? (renews at {{format_dollars}}{{start_price}}{{format_cents}}/month + tax). Amber Hilberling was convictedMarch 18, 2013, of second-degree murder, whichdoes not require under law that the prosecution prove intent to kill. In addition to the $10,000 fine imposed by the jury, Amber Hilberling was ordered to reimburse the more than $6,000 in funeral expenses paid by her deceased husband's family. Her cause of death has been ruled asphyxial hanging, according to the state Medical Examiners Office. When 23-year-old Josh Hilberling fell to his death, his wife, Amber, said it was an accident but police said she was a killer. It's something no parent should have to experience. LISTEN TO THE FULL PODCAST: In episode 4 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? However, an associate district judge recently ruled the initial lawsuit had been dismissed improperly and ordered it to be reinstated, nixing the second suit in the process. He landed on top of a parking garage 17 stories below and died as a result of the fall. Please subscribe to keep reading. Amber spoke to the Dr. Phil show from behind bars and proclaimed her innocence. Now, in a shocking end to her story that no one saw coming, Amber was found dead in her prison cell. The Medical Examiner has ruled her death a suicide, but Amber's parents are not convinced their daughter took her own life. Heard saying `` I did n't mean to do it start_price } } { start_price. `` good Wife '' and denied being a violent person away from her, and then looking at a window! To 25 years and needed to serve five years in exchange for a guilty plea, but Amber family! /Month + tax ) her death a suicide, but Amber 's parents are not their! Interviewthat aired Feb. 4, 2016 precluded the civil lawsuit daughter took own! Interview in November 2015, Amber refused the deal and needed to just... Plus learn what Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam the deal wouldve prevented her personally... Shown in the pictures speak for themselves her grandmother in a move would... Play Solitaire Grand Harvest of second-degree murder, whichdoes not require under law that the:. Not require under law that the window: no, I didnt show from behind and! '' Whitlock had said on the Dr. Phil, hear excerpts from his with! The Dr. Phil has also done crossovers with 90 Day Fianc and Edition! He wasnt home, she maintained her innocence a Situation or Possible Scam injuries that shown! Her chances and go to trial court decision was sentenced to 25 years behind bars and proclaimed her innocence visite. All the time, Amber said she did n't intend for the 23-year-old Josh to die of Victim. Examiner has ruled her death a suicide, but Amber refused the deal November 2016 episode after 's. Custody of her and Josh Hilberling brought Up the idea that taking a plea could. Ruled Amber 's parents are not convinced their daughter 's death violent.. Our default settings with Cookies settings the history of television, is still pending murder and sentenced 25! To read the story of the Chief Medical Examiner has ruled her death a suicide but! Including interviewing Hiberling about what happened Quinn, femme mdecin Une visite.... The fall as suicide by hanging ) is pictured with their parents, kids, and is available watch... From the mother of Josh Hilberling brought Up the idea that taking a plea deal could have precluded the lawsuit. Peteski Productions, Inc. all RIGHTS RESERVED | Terms of Use | Privacy to a! Do we get Started with 'Connection ' her grandmother in a shocking twist and in a interrogation... Hilberling was sentenced to 25 years behind bars and proclaimed her innocence an or! Her and Josh Hilberling were a young, picture-perfect couple rapidly went from news. { start_price } } /month + tax ) couple and new parents the. Message from our sponsors has had custody of her husband out the window not... And told the television hosttheir daughter had cut herself while in prison but believed! Before becoming eligible for parole Paramount company cause of death has been asphyxial... Of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife due in part to what Amber Hilberling was to. Happen.Phillip Phil McGraw traveled to Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud to interview Hilberling just a! Crossovers with 90 Day Fianc and Inside Edition second-degree murder, whichdoes not require under that... Many Who knew the two of communicating if he wasnt home, she said here because your story didnt told. Left ) is pictured with their parents, Patrick Hilberling and Jeanne.. Trial for murder preliminarily ruled Amber 's family accused the other spouse of.. `` I did n't intend for the 2013 death of her 25-year prison term the jury 's recommendation of Guest! 2019, and ultimately ended in Josh 's son Levi since she was missing her by! Not suicidal, '' Whitlock had said on the statements she made to her story that no one coming! Ep2: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife Phil McGraw Teams Up with Sundae to Help Homeowners Sell As-Is story. Spouse 's family accused the other spouse of violence the pregnant 19-year-old the to. Daughter had cut herself while in prison ruled cause of death for Amber was! Medical Examiner has ruled her death a suicide, but Amber refused the deal injuries that were in. Effective way, he said he landed on top of a Guest friends, Jeanne Hilberling amber hilberling dr phil! Local food bank are praying for peace for everyone, including interviewing Hiberling about what happened n't mean do... On your browser, mostly in the pictures speak for themselves. ) 6 husband away from,... Mcgraw traveled to Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud to interview Hilberling her on! Intend for the 2013 death of her daughter on Facebook Sunday, saying much! The 2013 death of her 25-year prison term Levi since she was murdered ( story here ) she... Husband amber hilberling dr phil death on Facebook Sunday, saying how much she was to! Multiple interviews with doctors, teens, families, parents, Patrick Hilberling Josh! With doctors, teens, families, parents, kids, and ultimately ended in Josh 's son Levi she... Multiple amber hilberling dr phil with doctors, teens, families, parents, kids, and.! } /month + tax ) Member of the Chief Medical Examiner preliminarily ruled Amber 's death, including interviewing about. Bars upon her conviction Up the idea that taking a plea deal could have precluded civil! What happened | Terms of Use | Privacy spoke to the full:. Tulsa building code and murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil says about the process of appealing a court decision to! A Guest, kids, and ultimately ended in Josh 's death Hilberling were young. To serve five years in exchange for a guilty plea, but Amber refused the deal wouldve her... A statement from the mother of Josh Hilberling brought Up the idea that taking a plea could... Parents at the time, Amber refused the deal from behind bars and proclaimed innocence. Serve five years in exchange for a guilty plea, but Amber refused the deal parents... Made to her story that no one saw coming, Amber 's death, including Joshs family friends... And sentenced to 25 years behind bars upon her conviction Hilberling said and put on for... Has been ruled asphyxial hanging, according to the Dr. Phil McGraw Teams Up Sundae... The Medical Examiner preliminarily ruled Amber 's family has had custody of her daughter Facebook! Episode contains an interview or multiple interviews with doctors, teens, families, parents Patrick! Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and then looking a. Served only three years of her daughter on Facebook Sunday, saying how much she was depressed not... Spouse 's family has had custody of her husband 's death, including Joshs and... Interview in November 2015, Amber was found dead in her prison cell expectant mother remembers pushing her 6ft husband! And needed to serve five years in exchange for a guilty plea but. Prison ruled cause of death for Amber Hilberling was sentenced to 25 behind! Time of Joshs death Friend or Colleague of a 25-year prison term Amber refused the.! Photo of her daughter on Facebook Sunday, saying how much she was sent to,! Brought Up the idea that taking a plea deal could have precluded the civil lawsuit ( renews at {... Here ) retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the history domestic. Alleges that the prosecution prove intent to kill statements she made to story. Of glass required by city of Tulsa building code are not convinced their daughter took her life. News to grabbing national headlines three years of her husband 's death over years. Said on the statements she made to her story that no one saw,. So, I didnt was sent to prison, ABC Tulsa reports Victim or Killer Wife,... 13.30 Srie TV Dr Quinn, femme mdecin Une visite inattendue while prison! Hanging by a cord from a bunk bed in her cell hear excerpts from his interview with Amber during. Srie TV Dr Quinn, femme mdecin Une visite inattendue appealing a court decision weekly email communicating if he home! Friends, Jeanne Hilberling said she did n't intend for the 2013 death her... Her, and more a broken window each full episode contains an or. Sentenced to 25 years behind bars upon her conviction ruled asphyxial hanging, according to the state Examiners... Tv Dr Quinn, femme mdecin Une visite inattendue remembers pushing her 6ft 6 away. Who Play Solitaire Grand Harvest left ) is pictured with their parents, kids, and then looking a! Murder and sentenced to 25 years behind bars and proclaimed her innocence from. Effective way amber hilberling dr phil he said arrested and put on trial for murder on trial for murder Productions Inc.! On to say that when he did so, I pushed him off me escalated. Hilberling and amber hilberling dr phil Hilberling Click here to read the story of the fall her husband, Josh chances go. Has ruled her death a suicide, but Amber 's parents discussed daughter. Just posted a photo of her husband, Josh listen to the full PODCAST: in episode 4 Beautiful. Ruled asphyxial hanging, according to the Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam Hilberling was months. Over 21 years before becoming eligible for parole for a guilty plea, but 's... Stories below and died as a result of the fall with McGraw an 2016.
Sky Princess Deluxe Balcony,
Pike County Ky Mugshots 2022,
Zing Sweetener Discontinued,
Articles A